Directed by:
- Steven Spielberg
- J.M. Barrie
- James V. Hart (as Jim V. Hart)
- Nick Castle
- Malia Scotch Marmo
- Dustin Hoffman ... Capt. Hook
- Robin Williams ... Peter Banning
- Julia Roberts ... Tinkerbell
- Bob Hoskins ... Smee
- Maggie Smith ... Granny Wendy
- Caroline Goodall ... Moira Banning
- Charlie Korsmo ... Jack 'Jackie' Banning
- Amber Scott ... Maggie Banning
- Laurel Cronin ... Liza, Wendy's Housekeeper
- Phil Collins ... Inspector Good
- Arthur Malet ... Tootles
- Isaiah Robinson ... Pockets
- Jasen Fisher ... Ace
- Dante Basco ... Rufio
- Raushan Hammond ... Thud Butt
- James Madio ... Don't Ask
- Thomas Tulak ... Too Small
- Alex Zuckerman ... Latchboy
- Ahmad Stoner ... No Nap
- Bogdan Georghe ... Lost Boy
- Adam McNatt ... Lost Boy
- René González Jr. ... Additional Lost Boy
- Brian Willis ... Additional Lost Boy
- Brett Willis ... Additional Lost Boy
- Ryan Francis ... Young Peter Pan
- Max Hoffman ... 5-Year-Old Peter Pan (as Maxwell Hoffman)
- Kelly Rowan ... Peter's Mother
- Stephanie Furst ... Mermaid
- Shannon Marie Kies ... Mermaid
- Regina Russell ... Mermaid
- Jewel Newlander Hubbard ... Peter Pan in Play
- Jeannine Renshaw ... Drama Teacher
- Rebecca Hoffman ... Jane in Play
- Jeannine Wagner ... Pianist
- Francesca Serrano ... Lost Boy in Play
- Kevin Gasca ... Lost Boy in Play
- Andre Bollinger ... Lost Boy in Play
- Lauren Friedler-Gow ... Lost Boy in Play
- Bryce Armstrong ... Lost Boy in Play
- Margie Takeda ... Lost Boy in Play
- Alyson Healing ... Lost Boy in Play
- Zoe Koehler ... Lost Boy in Play
- Scott Williamson ... Coach
- Wayne Aten ... Umpire
- Michael Hirshenson ... Umpire
- Jake Hoffman ... Little League Player (as Jacob Hoffman)
- Geoffrey Lower ... Brad
- Don S. Davis ... Dr. Fields
- Cameron Thor ... Ron
- Brad Blumenthal ... Jim
- Brenda Isaacs Booth ... Secretary (as Brenda Isaacs)
- Jan Cobler ... Secretary
- Ruth de Sosa ... Secretary
- Stuart White ... Chauffeur
- Gwyneth Paltrow ... Young Wendy
- Don McLeod ... Shadow
- Kim O'Kelley ... Prostitute
- Beverly Polcyn ... Prostitute
- Randi Pareira ... Prostitute
- Mary Bond Davis ... Prostitute
- David Crosby ... Tickles
- Nick Tate ... Noodler
- Tony Burton ... Bill Jukes
- Glenn Close ... Gutless
- Nick Ullett ... Pirate Jailer
- Matthew Van Ginkel ... Baby Peter Banning
- Ray Tveden ... Man in Stands
- Kim Robillard ... Toothless Cripple
- Michael Runyard ... Screaming Pirate (as Mike Runyard)
- Gary Epper ... Growling Pirate
- Robert Amico ... Pirate
- Jeff Bornstein ... Pirate
- Jimmy Buffett ... Shoe-Stealing Pirate
- Lonnie Burr ... Pegleg
- G. Larry Butler ... Baseball Game Attendee
- Brian DiMuccio ... Pirate
- Carrie Fisher ... Woman Kissing on Bridge
- Russell Gannon ... Blacksmith
- Tom Hodgins ... Pirate
- Rick Kleber ... Pirate
- George Lucas ... Man Kissing on Bridge
- Bruce Mahler ... Pirate
- Bruce Mercury ... The Drunk Pirate
- John Michael ... Doctor
- Lisa Wilhoit ... Baby Tinkerbell
- Mark Winn ... Praising Pirate
.